(no subject)

[windemere]

So, the best extra in the first Disk of the EE of the Hobbit AUJ is definitely the bit where Gandalf and Bilbo talk in the 'tunnel' before Rivendell. I loved everything else too, but that one just seemed to fit so well and I love Gandalf/Bilbo moments!

Comments

[cliodna-bright.livejournal.com]

I thought that scene was also awesome but the best was Elrond and Gandalf talking about the madness in Thorin's family and him overhearing it. That, and Elrond and Bilbo talking; I love that little setup for why the Elves like him and welcome him in Rivendell.

[eldanna.livejournal.com]

I liked those two scenes too, but I'd already seen them as preview clips. The other one was a surprise!